Jane Hawkins first consulted with plastic surgeon Dr. Ben Brown to talk about doing away with her breast implants and to have what’s referred to as a mini-mommy makeover, together with a tummy tuck and the use of fats from her frame to rebuild her breasts.Hawkins drove from Destin to peer Brown in Pensacola as a result of he got here extremely really useful by way of a pal and others, and he or she used to be in an instant inspired.Hawkins underwent a six-hour surgical procedure in November 2022. She woke up to search out Brown had finished the procedures she consented to and one process she mentioned she had now not sought after. Hawkins mentioned Brown put about 5 kilos of fats in her bottom.Quickly, the sutures in her abdomen was free. The wound, by the point she went to the emergency room used to be nine-inches-wide by way of four-inches-across, in keeping with some other physician.
“’He gave you utterly incorrect wound care directions,’ Hawkins remembered the physician announcing. ‘You seemed like you had a ribeye laying in your abdomen.’”Butcher or savior?Hawkins used to be one in every of no less than a dozen sufferers and previous workers of Gulf Breeze plastic surgeon Dr. Ben Brown of Repair Plastic Surgical procedure to return ahead to the Information Magazine with issues about his paintings following the demise of his 33-year-old spouse, Hillary Brown.The mummy of 3 went into cardiac arrest after Brown carried out a couple of procedures in his workplace, Nov. 21. She by no means regained awareness and died within the medical institution on Nov. 28. Hillary Brown’s demise is now below investigation by way of the Santa Rosa County Sheriff’s Place of job.
Whilst some sufferers advised the Information Magazine they’re proud of the procedures Brown carried out on them, others say Dr. Brown left them disfigured and coping with disabilities that can plague them for the remainder of their lives.Brown didn’t reply without delay to allegations made by way of sufferers on this tale. A spokesman for Brown launched a commentary that mentioned partially: “Ben is a devoted and extremely gifted surgeon, and not using a earlier disciplinary movements or marks.”A large number of calls and emails to the Florida Division of Well being and the Florida Board of Medication with questions on Brown’s observe have now not been returned. A web-based seek of a Board of Medication database finds the doctor has now not been cited for any disciplinary movements.For some sufferers, that’s laborious to imagine. Like Hawkins.Hawkins mentioned her abdomen sutures began opening about two weeks after her surgical procedure. There used to be such a lot fluid seeping from her incisions, Hawkins mentioned she used menstrual pads to soak it up. She mentioned Brown botched two in-office makes an attempt to near the ever-widening wound on her abdomen.“He began to sew up the perimeters of the place my opening used to be,” Hawkins described. “He is going, ‘I do not want this to separate any more,’ and I am like, ‘What?’ Then he mentioned I had to make use of an acetic acid and gauze to stay the world from getting inflamed and I needed to pack it. So, I did that for 2 weeks and I had acetic acid soaked in gauze packed into this opening that used to be seven-by-four inches extensive and most definitely an inch deep, no less than. My husband mentioned he may just see my muscle wall and he’s a 31-year veteran within the Military who has noticed a large number of stuff, so I accept as true with his opinion.”Hawkins additionally suffered from a situation referred to as necrosis after the surgical procedure, the place the surface dies from loss of move, which Brown additionally needed to reduce out of her abdominal.Hillary Brown demise:Dr. Ben Brown carried out a couple of procedures on spouse prior to her center stopped‘We don’t enjoy wounds like this’Her son Charlie Condon, who used to be 17 on the time, watched in frustration, concern and helplessness as his mom struggled to get better.“She will have died,” Condon mentioned. “To these days, I am nonetheless infuriated by way of the result as a result of we will be doing one thing, and he or she’ll nonetheless have ache.”Hawkins mentioned when she requested Brown in regards to the headaches, he introduced to accomplish apply up surgical procedures at no cost.“Right here’s what he mentioned to me,” Hawkins recalled. “’This does not occur. We do not enjoy wounds like this. My workforce isn’t skilled to take care of wound care.’ He mentioned, ‘That is all my fault, I take 100% duty. I can do those surgical procedures at no cost to mend this for you. I may not flip it into insurance coverage.’ I by no means took him up at the be offering to fix it as a result of I did not accept as true with him anymore.”Hawkins referred to as a pal who used to be a nurse in some other state who dropped the entirety to discuss with her in Florida.
“She mentioned, ‘We wish to move to the emergency room,’” mentioned Hawkins. “I went to the emergency room at Eglin Air Drive Base, at that medical institution in January. The physician mentioned, ’The one approach I am allowed to peer you is to deal with getting this wound wiped clean up and getting you closed up.’”And he or she mentioned, ‘According to what I am seeing right here, you might be 3 to 6 months from this wound being closed.’ Later, she advised me, ‘I used to be afraid that you’d move septic.’”Pensacola nurse Pleasure Edwards used to be recognized with breast most cancers in 2017. After present process chemotherapy and overcoming the sickness, she had a mastectomy and wanted reconstructive breast surgical procedure.Some other nurse, who used to be additionally a most cancers survivor, really useful Brown. Edwards and her husband consulted with Brown, who they are saying advised them he had a “99% luck price” together with her form of process. In 2019, he carried out the surgical procedure.“There have been headaches instantly,” mentioned Edwards, a nurse of 35 years. “I do know that one in every of my lungs were given nicked all through the surgical procedure, so after I got here out of surgical procedure, I additionally had a chest tube,” Edwards remembered.“Inside of 24 hours, the left facet began to fail, they usually took me again in looking to save that facet and that did not paintings. I will be able to be mindful the best facet, I used to be within the medical institution and a nurse used to be with me and we actually noticed the best facet, my nipple, the entirety simply grew to become black. She referred to as the physician (Ben Brown) and he or she defined that we had a drastic exchange in what seems like blood go with the flow, and he or she used to be advised that it used to be not anything to fret about.”Believing it used to be OK, Edwards went house however inside of days had extra issues.“The injuries weren’t simplest opening up they had been seeping, and it used to be foul smelling, inexperienced, simply pouring out of me and I will be able to be mindful calling his workplace and simply crying announcing, ‘There is something incorrect,” Edwards mentioned. “I used to be speaking with him that I felt like there used to be one thing very incorrect with me and I used to be at all times confident, ‘No, that is standard. That is one thing to be anticipated,’ even supposing I didn’t suppose it used to be standard.”After a month of coping with what gave the look to be an infection and not using a exchange within the end result, Edwards’ well being deteriorated the place she used to be now not ready to stroll, pressure or elevate her hands above her head. She mentioned Brown carried out surgical procedure on her once more to handle it and do reconstruction, however Edwards mentioned in a while she nonetheless had an infection.Sooner or later Brown admitted her to Sacred Middle Health facility, they usually put her on IV antibiotics, Edwards mentioned, and used a device to “blast out all the pus that used to be in there. There have been 4 hospital-acquired microorganisms rising within the wound.”Edwards mentioned she went to bodily treatment so to stroll and raise her hands generally once more. The wound on her chest remained open for 2 months and needed to be wiped clean and packed day-to-day to heal.Even 4 years after the surgical procedure, Edwards nonetheless takes medication for the nerve ache and has muscle spasms nearly day-to-day. She mentioned she didn’t pursue a criticism or litigation, as a result of after surviving most cancers and the ache of her reconstructive surgical procedure she simplest sought after to concentrate on the certain portions of her existence.’I did not query it. I simply, I thought him’Brandi Fitzsimmons is some other affected person who says she suffered everlasting injury after seeing Brown.
In October of 2021, Fitzsimmons mentioned Brown carried out a number of procedures on her together with a breast implant change, liposuction of her facets, again and hands, and fats injections in her hips. She additionally had a longer tummy tuck.On the other hand, the paintings didn’t prove like she had deliberate.Fitzsimmons mentioned the liposuction on her hands seems to be unfinished and left her with asymmetric lumps. She mentioned he additionally injected fats into her buttocks she didn’t need, and an incision in her abdomen spread out after the staples had been got rid of leaving an extended, deep “tunnel” in her abdomen that took a very long time to heal.She mentioned she had two, painful revision procedures in his workplace to handle the issues. What used to be intended to be a restoration strategy of about two weeks, in the end took a 12 months and a part.“Understanding now what we had been advised used to be standard,” mentioned Fitzsimmons, “That having a hollow, a tunnel on your abdomen, is standard and a part of the method, realizing now such a lot of different girls that experience had an identical eventualities, it is simply then I believe the guilt set in as a result of I did not say the rest faster. I did not query it. I simply, I thought him. We relied on him. I’m recovered, however nonetheless have nerve injury problems.”
Plastic surgeon gives insightDr. Josef Hadeed, MD, FACS, is a plastic surgeon with practices in each Miami, Florida, and Beverly Hills, California. He’s additionally the chair of the American Society of Plastic Surgeons Affected person Protection Committee.He mentioned it’s now not unusual for various sufferers to react another way to procedures relying on their age and well being, however repeated infections and incisions or holes which are gradual to heal is a priority.“Necrosis, fortunately, it isn’t one thing that is not unusual in cosmetic surgery,” mentioned Hadeed. “On the other hand, it’s one thing that may occur and there are specific procedures the place possibly it may well be a rather upper chance of creating necrosis.”Hadeed additionally mentioned post-surgery openings can happen when one thing is fighting enough therapeutic on the pores and skin, which may well be a subject matter with the surface’s floor or one thing deeper. He mentioned it may well be because of a loss of tough blood go with the flow to the world, pressure that reasons the world to drag aside, or therapeutic problems with the affected person.He mentioned maximum sufferers who’ve those issues reply neatly to conservative wound care like ensuring the injuries don’t dry out and retaining gauze in them till they heal.“Fortunately they are now not quite common, however I would not say that they are unusual,” Hadeed defined. “The vast majority of sufferers who’ve those problems do not want further surgical procedure or procedures. In some circumstances, you already know some stitches or sutures may also be positioned to deliver the surface edges again in combination and within the overwhelming majority of instances that is all that is wanted. It’s very unusual for a affected person to require further surgical procedure to handle those problems with pores and skin therapeutic.”Accolades from some former patientsOther sufferers of Brown’s mentioned he has carried out nice paintings on them for which they’re thankful.Melissa Whitmire has been going to Brown for years and used to be one in every of his first sufferers when he moved to the world in 2015. She mentioned he got rid of her implants, together with one who had ruptured, gave her a breast carry that grew to become out “extraordinarily just right” and that the process went “completely.”Such a lot in order that she persisted to peer him for various procedures for years, for the entirety from a neck carry, liposuction and fats injections, to laser therapies. “I had no destructive reports at any of my appointments,” mentioned Whitmire. “I felt like Dr. Brown used to be extraordinarily attentive. The physician does the most efficient he can, however surgical procedure is not foolproof.”Pat McCallum Farmer used to be additionally more than happy with the mommy makeover Brown gave her a number of years in the past, which incorporated breast implants, doing away with extra pores and skin, and a Brazilian butt carry.On the time, she had simply moved right here from Texas and had misplaced a large number of weight. Farmer mentioned she discovered Brown on-line and used to be inspired by way of what she learn and what she noticed in particular person.“I have been very, more than pleased, more than pleased and I used to be simply, I used to be bowled over after I noticed that (about Hillary Brown) and it is very unhappy for his circle of relatives, her circle of relatives, her kids and my center is going out to everybody concerned.”Ex-employees discuss outSome affected person proceedings come as no marvel to no less than two former workers of Brown’s.Shannon Gerage is Brown’s former workplace supervisor. She labored with him from 2018 to 2022, and mentioned she wore many hats for his industry together with clinical assistant, surgical procedure scheduler, receptionist, and felony and private assistant.Gerage mentioned when she first got to work for Brown he used to be “the most efficient,” even acting a a hit operation on her son’s eyes because of a start defect in addition to a mommy makeover on her.As time went on, she mentioned he looked as if it would have problem managing tension and when paintings issues arose, he every so often threw “tantrums” or was “paranoid” other people had been out to get him and he took out his frustrations at the workforce.Problems, she mentioned, that looked as if it would worsen when he went via a divorce along with his first spouse about two years in the past.“One minute he used to be thanking me for being the best pal and worker and day after today I used to be trash,” Gerage defined. “He mentioned we had been idiots and losers. Now not doing our jobs, stealing from him, as a result of he needed to do our jobs. He didn’t pay us, made me reduce worker hours so they might surrender as a result of he didn’t need anymore disgruntled workers after him.”Gerage mentioned Brown was so occupied with felony and private problems within the ultimate 12 months or so she labored for him he began getting “sloppy” with sufferers.“He didn’t care about sufferers anymore,” Gerage mentioned. “Affected person care used to be left as much as his PA and me. We mainly became a wound care facility. The PA used to be repeatedly treating infections, acting workplace procedures equivalent to reducing necrotic tissue and suturing wounds again closed. We had been repeatedly tracking affected person calls and texts on our mobile phones all hours of the day and night time, seven days every week. I’ve witnessed all of it and I felt so helpless.”Shut callsWhen Gerage heard about Hillary Brown’s demise she mentioned she wasn’t shocked as a result of she had witnessed an identical shut calls. One particularly took place in Brown’s Pensacola workplace round 2019 stood out to the previous worker.She mentioned Brown used to be acting a process on an aged girl along with his nurse practitioner within the room, when the nurse all at once got here out searching for an oxygen tank.Gerage mentioned they needed to move upstairs to the second one ground of the development to get it, as a result of they hardly used the oxygen tank, and produce it again downstairs the place the lady used to be.“Once I walked by way of I mentioned, ‘What the heck is occurring?’” Gerage recalled. “And our nurse practitioner mentioned, ‘We are shedding her.’ After which they took her tongue, they usually sutured it to her cheek so it would not impede her airway.“And (Brown) began freaking out,” Gerage persisted. “I wasn’t workplace supervisor on the time, however Dr. Brown yelled at our workplace supervisor announcing, ‘Don’t name the affected person’s husband. None of this will get out. You do not know the rest that simply took place. We were not doing rarely any procedures.’ She used to be simplest given positive drugs and at that time we simply roughly had been like, ‘What the hell?’ And we, the entire workforce, used to be simply roughly strolling from side to side going, ‘Oh my God, oh my God, what are we doing?’ And after all anyone, I am not certain who it used to be, referred to as 911, were given them there they usually transported her off to the medical institution.”Gerage mentioned the lady’s husband arrived to pick out her up after she have been transported they usually instructed him she used to be within the medical institution the place Gerage mentioned she recovered.Gerage mentioned the loss of affected person care and turmoil at paintings sooner or later took a toll on her house and paintings existence and he or she surrender. “I might have left faster, however my co-workers weren’t ready to surrender and I felt I wished to give protection to them,” Gerage mentioned. “I watched him get out of such a lot of violations and court cases, I couldn’t stick round and watch sufferers and workers undergo anymore.”Debra Brown Man, no relation to Dr. Ben Brown, additionally labored for him for approximately 3 and a part weeks in September 2022. Man mentioned her time along with his workplace used to be reduce brief as a result of Brown fired her for writing a letter outlining her issues about affected person protection.Man, a surgical technologist, used to be liable for retaining a sterile atmosphere for in-office procedures, together with cleansing equipment and kit. From her first day, Man mentioned she used to be appalled at Brown’s refusal to apply fundamental protection protocols.
Man mentioned she used to be recommended to make use of a bucket with distilled water to scrub bloody tools or within the worker front room the place they ate. Man supplied a duplicate of the letter she despatched Dr. Brown along side footage of the “sterile procedure room,” which regarded extra like a provide closet with stacks of packing containers and different apparatus across the room.Man mentioned she witnessed Brown many times carry out procedures in his workplace with out right kind apparatus, workforce or in a sterile atmosphere. She mentioned one girl even awoke all through a face carry Brown used to be functioning on her and requested to make use of the toilet, which the physician allowed her to do even supposing Man mentioned it wasn’t protected or sanitary.When the lady returned to complete the process, she started vomiting in every single place the room from the drugs Brown had them administer to sedate her.“My surgical judgment of right and wrong would now not permit me to stick in that atmosphere,” mentioned Man. “I’ve at all times been an recommend for my sufferers. Once I did this there, I used to be chastised. I was their enemy. Once I faced them and requested for a gathering out of outrage, they fired me. I noticed and witnessed greater than I will be able to ever put out of your mind.”Man filed a criticism with the Florida Company for Healthcare Management however gained no reaction.She mentioned she additionally knowledgeable North Florida Surgeons (NFS) of her issues, a area of expertise surgical staff Brown used to be affiliated with, however Man mentioned she used to be advised by way of workforce “if they’d additional questions their legal professional would touch” her. She mentioned she didn’t listen from NFS once more.Calls to the Florida Division of Well being and North Florida Surgeons for remark weren’t returned. What’s subsequent within the Hillary Brown investigation?The Santa Rosa Sheriff’s Place of job and the clinical examiner are investigating Hillary Brown’s demise however say it may well be a number of months prior to her explanation for demise is made up our minds as a result of they’re ready on toxicology studies.
District 1 Scientific Examiner Dr. Deanna Oleske mentioned even if she has the result of the younger girl’s post-mortem, it is going to be as much as the State Legal professional’s Place of job to unencumber them on account of the ordinary nature of the case.Consistent with a Santa Rosa County Sheriff’s Place of job incident record, Brown referred to as 911 from his Repair Plastic Surgical procedure workplace within the Tiger Level house of Gulf Breeze round 4:15 p.m., on Nov. 21.The responding deputy’s name notes said Hillary Brown used to be within the strategy of a number of surgeries when she had a number of seizures and went into cardiac arrest. The decision notes additionally said the physician perhaps overmedicated the affected person.Hillary Brown’s father, Marty Ellington, mentioned he and her mom, Dixie, are devastated over the lack of their daughter. He mentioned they’ve many unanswered questions on what took place when Brown used to be acting procedures on her in his workplace, and he or she went into cardiac arrest.Hillary Brown used to be within the medical institution every week prior to she used to be got rid of from existence give a boost to as a result of her mind had long past with out oxygen for too lengthy.“We had been within the ICU with Ben for 5 days,” Ellington mentioned. “Time and again asking him what took place. He by no means advised us of any seizures, simplest that she collapsed and used to be unresponsive. This used to be the primary we heard of seizures, but when securing her tongue is what he used to be regarding, this is time wasted he will have used to accomplish CPR,” Ellington mentioned.There are not any regulations in opposition to medical doctors acting procedures on members of the family in Florida, however the American Scientific Affiliation does now not counsel it.“That is one thing that there is not any transparent consensus on,” mentioned Dr. Hadeed. “It utterly is determined by the relaxation stage of each the surgeon and the circle of relatives member. Some other people would really feel comfy doing it, whilst others would now not. It’s one thing that isn’t essentially inspired, however other people do it anyway.”Brown has additionally now not spoke back to requests for remark or an interview, however he has employed a public family members company that launched a commentary on behalf of his circle of relatives which reads partially: “Ben is totally devastated by way of the unexpected lack of his loving spouse Hillary, and is desperately looking to know the way to are living in the future, by no means thoughts an entire life with out her by way of his facet,” Crimson Banyan wrote on behalf of “the circle of relatives of Dr. Ben Brown.”“His deep grief and surprise is simplest compounded by way of many mistruths circulating on-line and within the media. The procedures Ben carried out at the day of Hillary’s passing had been minor and regimen. All protection and clinical protocols had been strictly adopted, and the procedures came about all through workplace hours with the give a boost to of Ben’s clinical workforce.”Within the interim, some former sufferers, need him to forestall working towards medication.”I without a doubt really feel like Dr. Brown must by no means observe once more,” mentioned Pleasure Edwards. “He must now not have a clinical license and he must now not observe. I am happy to listen to that they will be investigating the instances of his spouse’s demise. I believe that there must be an intensive investigation and I believe like he wishes to visit trial for it.”
Jane Hawkins has employed felony suggest to appear into her case. She mentioned the wounds and drastic adjustments to her frame have dramatically modified her existence. She and her husband stay buddies however are splitting up after years in combination as it has taken an emotional and bodily toll on their marriage.Hawkins additionally filed a record with the Santa Rosa Sheriff’s Place of job in opposition to Brown alleging attack for the process he carried out on her with out consent.The Sheriff’s Place of job didn’t handbag the criticism, Hawkins mentioned, as a result of deputies advised her it used to be a question for the Florida Division of Well being and the Florida Board of Medication, which examine proceedings in opposition to physicians.“Here is what I wish to occur,” mentioned Hawkins. “I do not want him to harm somebody else, proper? Whether or not or now not I ever see monetary repayment from this, that guy must be stopped.”
