‘What’s flawed?’: The silence of Pakistanis on expulsion of Afghan refugees – The Gentleman Report | World | Business | Science | Technology | Health
Today: Jul 15, 2025

‘What’s flawed?’: The silence of Pakistanis on expulsion of Afghan refugees

‘What’s flawed?’: The silence of Pakistanis on expulsion of Afghan refugees
November 22, 2023



Islamabad, Pakistan – They had been a commonplace sight throughout main Pakistani towns, appearing low-paying salary paintings – loading items at markets, pushing carts on streets to promote vegetables and fruit, or choosing trash.
However for the reason that starting of the month, the ones Afghans were lacking from public view after the Pakistan authorities ordered a crackdown on undocumented refugees and migrants, just about 1.7 million of them from the neighbouring nation.
Air conditioner technician Raza Ali, who works in a significant electronics marketplace in Lahore, Pakistan’s second-largest town within the japanese Punjab province, informed Al Jazeera he was once “now not pals with them, however they had been all the time round”.
“However for the reason that authorities began its crackdown, they simply vanished. It may well be excellent for us as a result of now our other people can do their jobs,” the 31-year-old informed Al Jazeera.
“Glance, they weren’t from right here. If the federal government is sending them again to their very own nation, what’s flawed with that? I believe that is the proper choice. But even so, I didn’t know them. It does now not make any distinction to my lifestyles,” he added nonchalantly.
Ali’s sentiments possibly provide an explanation for the muted reaction of commonplace Pakistanis to the expulsion of the Afghan refugees, a lot of whom had been born in Pakistan and had by no means noticed Afghanistan.

The Afghan migration to Pakistan started within the past due Seventies after the Soviets invaded their nation. Then, the Afghans got here in additional waves after the USA attacked Afghanistan within the aftermath of the 9/11 assaults and the newer Taliban takeover of Kabul in 2021.
The Pakistani authorities, whose expulsion marketing campaign started on November 1, says 1.7 million of just about 4 million Afghan refugees in Pakistan had been undocumented. Islamabad blames the refugees for a contemporary spike in assaults by means of armed teams, maximum of them performed by means of Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), sometimes called Pakistani Taliban as a result of its ideological affinity with the Afghan Taliban.
Pakistan’s caretaker Inner Minister Sarfraz Bugti, the highest authorities authentic supervising the expulsion force, final month alleged that 14 out of 24 suicide bombings within the nation this yr had been performed by means of Afghan nationals.
Ultimate week, he informed the parliament greater than 300,000 Afghans left the rustic this month, in spite of grievance from the United Countries and rights teams over forcibly using the refugees and migrants away.
However there is not any visual outrage over the transfer inside of Pakistan – a silence being contrasted by means of their anger over Israel’s compelled displacement – and what many mavens name a genocide – of Palestinian civilians in Gaza.
‘Nice deal of racism’
Gallup Pakistan, in a survey performed within the first week of November, discovered that 84 p.c of respondents “strongly licensed” the federal government’s transfer to expel the “unlawful” refugees and migrants, basically from Afghanistan.
Additionally, an awesome 64 p.c of the respondents stated the repatriation of the Afghans would result in advanced safety and peace in Pakistan.
Afghan refugees settle in a camp near the Torkham Pakistan-Afghanistan border in Torkham, Afghanistan, Saturday.Afghan youngsters at a camp close to the Torkham border in Afghanistan [File: Ebrahim Noroozi/AP]
Muhammed Rehan, a bookstall proprietor in Karachi, the rustic’s greatest town and a shelter for tens of 1000’s of Afghans, stated whilst the federal government choice can have been guided by means of the “frustration” over its incapability to keep watch over the expanding violence, he agreed with the reasoning in their expulsion.
“The verdict to repatriate undocumented other people is the right kind one. There are numerous legal parts amongst them, and police should take care that they simply arrest those that are with out papers or those that have dedicated any crime,” he informed Al Jazeera.
In a similar way, Adil Musa, an actual property broker within the capital Islamabad, additionally counseled the federal government’s choice, pronouncing it is going to lend a hand the legislation and order state of affairs.
“Those Afghan households additionally impacted the condo marketplace in Islamabad, making it tough for the locals to procure assets,” he informed Al Jazeera.
However Pakistani sociologist Nida Kirmani believes there’s a “nice deal of racism” in opposition to the Afghans in Pakistan, which she says is because of years of “state-sponsored brainwashing” that framed the Afghans as enemies.
Kirmani, affiliate professor of sociology at Lahore College of Control Science, informed Al Jazeera the Pakistani state portrays the Afghans as “terrorists”, even if the state equipment itself was once central to the expansion of teams such because the Taliban in Afghanistan.
“Many of us right here have purchased into those narratives. Plus, every now and then of financial lack of confidence and upheaval, we steadily see a upward push in xenophobic discourses and actions. The present situation is a part of this common pattern, and Afghans turn out to be simple scapegoats,” she stated.
Karachi-based attorney Sara Malkani claims there was once “some resistance” by means of the civil society teams to the federal government’s choice. One reason why for the muted public outrage, she stated, may well be as a result of the fears of state suppressing mass anti-government protests.
“There’s public sympathy in some quarters, and there are activists who’re looking to call for the federal government must deliver extra transparency within the [expulsion] processes, however there’s a wish to teach other people on why Afghans selected to flee Afghanistan and what function did the Pakistani state play in perpetuating the stipulations in Afghanistan,” she informed Al Jazeera.
Malkani stated you will need to alternate the general public belief inside of Pakistan concerning the Afghans, who’re going again to a rustic impoverished by means of many years of war and which is now going through a political and humanitarian disaster.
“Below the present Taliban authorities, we’re already seeing common gender apartheid, with ladies denied the proper to schooling and girls denied the proper to employment and mobility. It’s unconscionable to forcibly deport them [to face these problems],” she stated.

OpenAI
Author: OpenAI

Don't Miss

The United Kingdom says 1000’s of Afghans had been dropped at Britain below a secret resettlement program

The United Kingdom says 1000’s of Afghans had been dropped at Britain below a secret resettlement program

LONDON (AP) — 1000’s of Afghans, together with many that labored with
Fox Information Megastar Hits Trump With A Chilly Fact About His Dating With Vladimir Putin

Fox Information Megastar Hits Trump With A Chilly Fact About His Dating With Vladimir Putin

Fox Information leader political analyst Brit Hume on Monday mentioned something is